Checking Array For Title - Exiting For Loop

i want to check my array for a title, if the title is there i want to call a method, if the title is not there i want an error message. I am not sure how to get this. i think my code would work if it didn't always finish the method. for example if true the method stops and does run whats after the for loop. but that isn't happening.

void markItemOnLoan(String title, String name, String date){
int i=0;
for (i = 0; i < numberOfItems; i++){
if (items[i].getTitle().equals(title)){
items[i].markOnLoan(name,date);
}
}
System.out.println("ERROR: Can not find that item. ");
}