Counter And Score Variables In Jeopardy Game?

Most of my code is done for making this Jeopardy game, the only problem I seem to have is to have variables that retain values after going through a loop, in this case the variables counter and score in the method responsePrompt

After going through the 25 questions, the value counter remains at 1, and score is either 1 or -1, nothing more, nothing less. I've had the variables initialized at 1 both inside and outside of the for loop. Full code below just in case it's something outside the method

import java.util.*;
import java.io.*;
public class Project10
{
public static void main(String[] args)
throws java.io.IOException

[Code] ....