Queries :: Populate Blank Table With All Values From Another Table

I have two tables (Table 1, Table 2). Table 1 is blank and has the fields "Field1, Field2, and Field3." Table 2 has data and 10 different fields ("Field1, Field2", etc). I want to copy all data from the matching fields in Table 2 to the corresponding Table 1. I've tried an Update Query in design view. Did not join any records, and just a simple:

Field: Field 1
Table: Table 1
Update To: [Table2]![Field5]

This returns 0 records to update. I thought about a Make Table to override the entire Table, but that isn't working either.