2 Querys Not Returning The Same Data

I have two databases with table structures exactly the same. The query in one database works and returns correctly. The same query (copied and pasted) in another database returns the correct records but completely ignores the order by. Even stranger, when you are creating the query under modify and run it, it is fine. But when I right-click on the query and go to 'Open View' then the query does not return correctly. Below is the query:

SELECT TOP (100) PERCENT pf.description AS incentive, CAST(i.targetc AS FLOAT) AS targetc, i.targetp, b.basis, d.description, i.iSelect, i.direction, pf.pValue,
pf.pFigure
FROM dbo.PerfFactorWeights AS pfw INNER JOIN
dbo.PerfFactors AS pf ON pfw.incentiveID = pf.incentiveID INNER JOIN
dbo.Incentive AS i ON pfw.incentiveID = i.incentiveID AND pfw.basis = i.basisID INNER JOIN
dbo.Basis AS b ON i.basisID = b.basisID INNER JOIN
dbo.Division AS d ON pfw.division = d.uniqueID
ORDER BY incentive, d.uniqueID, b.basis