STUMPED: Why Doesn't This Procedure Work?

I have been looking at this for over a day now. I cannot see why this procedure does not work, its so simple.

No matter what happens it always returns 0. If it locates a record, it doesnt update it, yet it still returns 0.

It should not be returning 0 if its not updating so I can't figure out why it does.

Why does this always return 0?

[pre]Create Procedure CreateNewCategory
 @title nvarchar(100),
 @description nvarchar(1000),
 @displayOrder int
AS
 DECLARE @Result as int

IF EXISTS(SELECT categoryTitle FROM categories WHERE categoryTitle = @title)
 BEGIN
  SELECT @Result = 1
 END
ELSE
 BEGIN
  INSERT INTO categories(categoryTitle, categoryDescription, displayOrder)
  VALUES(@title, @description, @displayOrder)
 
  /* If no error was encountered, 0 will be returned. */
  SELECT @Result = @@Error
 END
GO
[/pre]

Thanks!