Can Decrease To Accomodate Contents Not Working For Subsequent Pages?

This is an example of my data:

Col1 Col2 Col3
1 LONGDESCRIPTION1 111
1 LONGDESCRIPTION1 222
1 LONGDESCRIPTION1 333
1 LONGDESCRIPTION1 444
2 LONGDESCRIPTION2 XXX
2 LONGDESCRIPTION2 YYY
2 LONGDESCRIPTION2 XYZ
2 LONGDESCRIPTION2 999

This is an example of what I want my report to look like (ill put row numbers to help identify)

Col1 Col2 Col3 Row Num
1 LONGDESCRIPTION1 111 1
222 2
333 3
444 4
Subtotal Col3Sum (PAGEBREAK)
2 LONGDESCRIPTION2 XXX 5
YYY 6
XYZ 7
999 8
Subtotal Col3Sum

The Settings:
I'm currently using a single TABLE DETAIL ROW with HIDE DUPLICATES in Col1 and Col2.
The LONGDESCRIPTION field can be expected to take 2 row heights worth of space because it wont fit.
I've also got CAN INCREASE TO ACCOMODATE CONTENTS and CAN DECREASE TO ACCOMODATE CONTENTS selected.

The Problem:
When Printing/PrintPreviewing Page1, the Height of Rows 2/3/4 ARE THE CORRECT SIZE (only 1 row high, meaning that can decrease to accomodate contents works).
BUT when Printing/PrintPreviewing Page2, the Height of Rows 6/7/8 FOLLOW THE HEIGHT of ROW 5 (two rows high, meaning that can decrease to accomodate contents DOES NOT WORK).

Rows 2/3/4 has the same Row Height as Row 1 ONLY ON PAGES after Page1.
Rows 6/7/8 has the same Row Height as Row 5 ONLY ON PAGES after Page1.

Can decrease to accomodate contents does not seem to be working for Pages after page 1.